Skip to the content

Find Out How Much You Can Save Today

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Read what satisfied customers have said about Warren Insurance Agency.
See All Reviews
See All ReviewsSee All Reviews

Quotes From Multiple Companies

Central Co-Operative Insurance Logo
Dryden Mutual Insurance Company Logo
Erie Insurance Logo
Millville Mutual Insurance Logo
The Progressive Corporation Logo

Your Local Ithaca Independent Insurance Agency

Warren Insurance Agency specializes in auto, home, life, and business insurance.

Warren Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency located in Ithaca, New York. They proudly represent Erie Insurance and offer a number of great insurance products, including home insurance, auto insurance, and commercial insurance.

James Warren, owner of Warren Insurance, has always enjoy helping people and getting them the most for their money. That is exactly what James and Warren Insurance Agency will do for you! Contact them today to find out more about how they can help with any of your insurance issues or questions.

Specializing In Erie Insurance

Erie Insurance has been helping customers since 1925 with their auto, home, business, and life insurance needs.
Click here to get an auto insurance quote with Erie Insurance "ERIE Auto Insurance Quote" (opens in new tab)
Click here to pay your Erie Insurance bill "ERIE Pay Your Bill" (opens in new tab)
Click here to use the Erie Insurance Life Insurance Calculator "ERIE Life Insurance Calculator" (opens in new tab)
Auto Insurance

Auto Insurance

Auto or car insurance coverage has two parts. The first is the liability section of the policy.
Homeowners Insurance

Homeowners
Insurance

If you have tangible assets, you need the protection of a homeowners insurance policy.
Individual Life Insurance

Life
Insurance

Always on the lookout for quality, service-oriented insurance companies for our clients.
Boat & Marine Insurance

Boat & Marine
Insurance

Boat or marine insurance is available for small boats, yachts and high performance powerboats.
Flood Insurance

Flood
Insurance

Did you know that your homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage?
Business Insurance

Business Insurance

As a business owner, you have enough on your mind without having to worry about your insurance needs.

Recent News & Updates

​What to Do After a Hit and Run​

​What to Do After a Hit and Run​

Posted: August 4, 2026

Getting in a car accident is enough to ruin anyone's day. But if you’re involved in a hit-and-run, the experience can be especially disorienting. You realize that your vehicle’s been hit and before you can step out to get the other driver’s information, their car is taking off into the distance. As overwhelming as the experience can be, how you react next can play an...

When Should I Call My Insurance Agent?

When Should I Call My Insurance Agent?

Posted: August 4, 2026

An insurance agent isn’t just someone who can sell you a policy. Whether you have a question about your coverage, need to file a claim or change your policy, your agent can provide insurance solutions to a seemingly countless number of issues you might run into. And the conversations you have with your agent can help provide protection from the unknown and greater peace of...

General Liability Insurance 101: A Foundation for Every Small Business

General Liability Insurance 101: A Foundation for Every Small Business

Posted: August 4, 2026

If you own a small business, you've likely heard that general liability insurance is something you should have. But what exactly does it cover, and why is it considered such an important part of a business insurance plan? General liability insurance—sometimes called GL insurance or commercial general liability—is one of the most fundamental types of coverage available to businesses of all sizes. Understanding how it...

Insurance products are offered through the following insurers: Central Co-Operative Insurance (Baldwinsville, NY); Dryden Mutual Insurance Company (Dryden, NY); Erie Insurance (Erie, PA); Millville Mutual Insurance (Millville, PA); The Progressive Corporation (Mayfield Village, OH); and other unaffiliated insurers.

Insurance services are provided by an independent insurance agency. Warren Insurance Agency and its producers are licensed in the states where services are offered. License numbers are available upon request. Availability, eligibility, and coverages may vary by state. Not all products are available in all states.